Updated at: 24-07-2023 - By: John Lau

As a fitness enthusiast or someone simply looking to make healthier choices, you may find yourself debating between Muscle Milk and Fairlife when seeking high-protein beverages.

Both options have gained popularity in the health and wellness world, offering nutritional benefits for different needs and goals.

In this blog post, we will take an in-depth look at Muscle Milk vs Fairlife by comparing their ingredients, nutritional content, benefits and drawbacks to help you choose the best option for your lifestyle.

What Are Muscle Milk And Fairlife?

Muscle Milk Vs Fairlife (1)

Muscle Milk and Fairlife are both protein shakes that cater to fitness enthusiasts who want a quick, convenient way to get their daily dose of protein.

Ingredients And Nutritional Information

Navigating the world of protein shakes can be challenging, especially for individuals recovering from alcoholism, as maintaining a well-balanced diet to support sobriety becomes pivotal.

Muscle Milk contains high-quality proteins like milk-derived calcium caseinatewhey protein isolate, and sodium caseinate.

While it offers a substantial amount of protein per serving (up to 32 grams), along with carbs (19g) for sustained energy, it also includes some artificial ingredients and added sugars that could affect one’s overall health goals.

On the other hand, Fairlife shakes provide similar levels of protein through ultra-filtered lactose-free milk in their Core Power range; they boast lower sugar content than regular milk while being rich in calcium and vitamin D.

Getting familiarized with these factors is highly valuable when looking for alternatives that cater not only to fitness-driven goals but address specific dietary restrictions or requirements related to your wellness journey after alcoholism.

Flavors And Varieties Available

For those looking to incorporate protein shakes into their routine, both Muscle Milk and Fairlife offer a range of flavors and varieties to suit different taste preferences and nutritional needs. This allows individuals in recovery from alcoholism to find suitable options that support their health goals. Here are some popular choices from each brand:

Muscle Milk:

  • Chocolate
  • Vanilla Crème
  • Strawberries ‘n Crème
  • Cookies ‘n Crème
  • Banana Crème

Fairlife Core Power High Protein Shakes (lactose-free):

  • Rich Chocolate
  • Smooth Vanilla
  • Very Strawberry
  • Dairy ‘Licious

These diverse flavor options make it easy for people in recovery from alcoholism to find a protein shake they enjoy while working towards rebuilding their physical health.

Target Audience

Muscle Milk and Fairlife products cater to a diverse group of consumers, ranging from athletes and bodybuilders to fitness enthusiasts looking for an effective post-workout recovery option.

For example, people who have struggled with alcoholism may experience muscle weakness or atrophy due to poor nutrition and reduced protein intake. Muscle Milk’s essential amino acids help promote muscle growth and repair, while Fairlife’s lactose-free formula combined with calcium and vitamin D offers a more suitable alternative for those with dietary restrictions.

Nutritional Comparison

Muscle Milk Vs Fairlife (2)

Muscle Milk and Fairlife have varying nutritional content, with differences in protein quality, fat source, carbohydrate and sugar content, as well as vitamin and mineral composition.

Protein Content And Quality

Muscle Milk and Fairlife protein shakes are popular supplements for those looking to build lean muscle or support their workout recovery. When it comes to protein content and quality, both brands offer high-quality sources of protein.

Muscle Milk contains a blend of whey and casein proteins, while Fairlife uses ultra-filtered milk that is higher in protein than regular milk.

However, there are slight differences in the amount of protein per serving between the two brands, with Fairlife offering slightly more at 30 grams per serving compared to Muscle Milk’s 25 grams per serving.

Additionally, if you have dietary restrictions such as lactose intolerance or gluten sensitivity, Fairlife may be a better option due to its lactose-free and gluten-free nature.

Fat Content And Source

The fat content and source in both Muscle Milk and Fairlife vary depending on the flavor and variety. While Muscle Milk can contain up to 4.5 grams of saturated fat per servingFairlife’s protein shakes are low in saturated fat with only 1 gram per serving.

Additionally, Fairlife uses filtered low-fat grade A milk as the protein source, which means it contains naturally occurring fats that promote good health compared to artificial sources found in some other products.

Carbohydrate And Sugar Content

When it comes to comparing Muscle Milk and Fairlife in terms of carbohydrate and sugar content, there are some significant differences between the two. Fairlife’s Fat-Free Ultra-Filtered Milk contains half the carbohydrates and sugar as standard skim milk, making it a great option for those looking to reduce their carbohydrate intake or manage their blood sugar levels.

On the other hand, Muscle Milk Protein does contain some carbohydrates, with 3g per serving. However, this is relatively low compared to other protein powders like Core Power Performance which have almost half carbs with 93% of them coming from added sugar.

In summary, if you’re someone who needs to watch your carb or sugar intake carefully (such as those with alcoholism), then Fairlife might be a better choice for you due to its lower carbohydrate and sugar content than Muscle Milk Protein and alternatives such as Core Power Performance.

Vitamin And Mineral Composition

Muscle Milk and Fairlife are both great sources of essential vitamins and minerals. Muscle Milk, in particular, contains about 12% to 15% of iodine, magnesium, copper, zinc, and potassium per serving.

It also boasts an impressive amount of chromium at 40%. Fairlife milk is filtered into five components- water, butterfat, protein, vitamins, and minerals. This process strips the milk off impurities while leaving behind all the nutritious elements such as vitamin D and calcium that are vital for muscle growth and recovery.

Calories Per Serving

It is essential to pay attention to the calories per serving of Muscle Milk and Fairlife if you’re concerned about your calorie intake. While Muscle Milk generally contains 150-180 calories per serving, Fairlife Fat-Free Ultra-Filtered Milk contains only 80 calories per cup.

This low-calorie content can make it an excellent choice for those with weight loss goals or a desire to manage their calorie intake carefully. Additionally, both products offer protein shakes suitable for meal replacement with similar calorie counts of around 150 calories per serving.

Benefits And Drawbacks Of Muscle Milk

Muscle Milk Vs Fairlife (3)

Muscle Milk supports muscle growth and recovery due to its essential amino acids, while also providing sustained energy; however, it may contain artificial ingredients and has more calories and sugar than Fairlife.

Supports Muscle Growth And Recovery

Muscle Milk is a popular protein supplement that has gained widespread use among athletes and bodybuilders looking to support muscle growth and recovery.

Its high protein content, essential amino acids, and sustained energy make it ideal for those engaging in intense physical activity. However, some experts have raised concerns about the artificial sweeteners used in Muscle Milk, which may cause side effects such as bloating or gastrointestinal distress.

Alternatively, Fairlife offers lactose-free milk with added protein which can provide the same benefits without any potential negative effects from artificial sweeteners.

Includes Essential Amino Acids

Muscle Milk and Fairlife protein shakes are both packed with essential amino acids, which are vital for building muscle. Essential amino acids cannot be produced by the body on their own, so it is important to get them from external sources such as protein supplements.

Muscle Milk contains a range of essential amino acids including leucine, valine, and isoleucine, while Fairlife’s shakes contain whey protein which also has all of the essential amino acids needed for muscle growth.

By incorporating these supplements into your diet alongside regular exercise, you can support the growth and maintenance of healthy muscles.

Provides Sustained Energy

Muscle Milk is a great source of energy due to the high protein content that provides sustained energy throughout the day. It’s perfect for those who need extra fuel during long workouts or busy days.

The ingredients in Muscle Milk promote muscle recovery, which can help reduce fatigue and improve overall performance.

On the other hand, while Fairlife doesn’t offer as much sustained energy as Muscle Milk does, it does have lower sugar content and more calcium and vitamin D than regular milk.

Core Power High Protein Shakes by Fairlife are also lactose-free and gluten-free, making them a good option for those with dietary restrictions.

May Contain Artificial Ingredients

It’s important to be cautious when choosing protein drinks like Muscle Milk, as they may contain artificial ingredients that could potentially cause side effects.

These sweeteners have been known to interact with gut bacteria and lead to digestive discomfort or other health problems. In fact, some research has linked certain types of artificial sweeteners found in protein drinks to an increased risk of developing alcoholism or other addictive disorders.

Contains More Calories And Sugar Than Fairlife

Muscle Milk, while popular among fitness enthusiasts for its high protein content, may not be the best option for those watching their calorie and sugar intake.

Compared to Fairlife, Muscle Milk contains more calories and sugar per serving. This can be a drawback for individuals with certain health conditions such as alcoholism which may require them to limit their sugar intake.

However, Muscle Milk does have its benefits, including providing sustained energy and essential amino acids necessary for muscle growth and recovery.

Benefits And Drawbacks Of Fairlife

Fairlife has a higher protein content than regular milk, lower sugar content, and is lactose-free and gluten-free, making it a suitable option for those with dietary restrictions; however, it may be more expensive than Muscle Milk and its flavors may not suit everyone’s taste preferences.

Higher Protein Content Than Regular Milk

If you’re looking to increase your protein intake, Fairlife milk is a great option to consider. Compared to regular milk, Fairlife skim milk has 62.5% more protein and is also lactose-free and gluten-free.

Additionally, their Elite protein shakes have a whopping 42g of protein per serving, making them ideal for those with muscle-building goals or anyone seeking an elite source of high-quality protein.

Lower Sugar Content Than Regular Milk

Fairlife milk has a lower sugar content than regular milk, which is great news for those looking to reduce their sugar intake. According to numbers, Fairlife’s Fat-Free Ultra-Filtered Milk contains half the carbohydrates and sugar as standard skim milk.

Additionally, Fairlife chocolate milk has a higher protein content and lower fat content than regular chocolate milk but still contains more added sugars. However, if you are looking for a delicious way to incorporate more protein into your diet without sacrificing taste or quality, then Fairlife may be worth considering.

Lactose-free And Gluten-free

For those living with lactose intolerance or gluten intolerance, finding milk alternatives can be a daunting task. Fairlife offers a solution with their lactose-free and gluten-free ultra-filtered milk.

This type of milk is perfect for those looking to improve their digestive health as it eliminates the discomfort caused by lactose or gluten consumption. Additionally, Fairlife’s ultra-filtering process removes impurities while preserving calcium absorption and increasing protein intake.

Rich In Calcium And Vitamin D

Dairy foods like Fairlife are rich in calcium and vitamin D, which are important nutrients for the body. Calcium not only plays a crucial role in building strong bones but also helps muscles and nerves function properly.

Similarly, vitamin D is essential for maintaining healthy bones and teeth by aiding in the absorption of calcium from food. In fact, experts recommend that adults consume 1,000-1,200 mg of calcium daily and around 600-800 IU of vitamin D per day to ensure optimal health.

Your body cannot produce these essential nutrients naturally, so it is vital to include dairy products like Fairlife Chocolate 2% Ultra-Filtered Milk or Vitamin D supplements into your daily diet to meet your nutrient needs.

May Be More Expensive Than Muscle Milk

Fairlife protein shakes are often more expensive than Muscle Milk, with a price tag of well over $2 per serving. If you’re on a tight budget, this can be a significant drawback to choosing Fairlife as your go-to protein supplement.

While Fairlife does offer some benefits over other options, such as being lactose-free and gluten-free, the cost may not be worth it for those who don’t have the means to spend extra money on their sports nutrition needs.

Which One Should You Choose?

Consider your goal, dietary restrictions, taste preferences, and budget before choosing between Muscle Milk and Fairlife. If you aim to build muscle or support muscle recovery with a balanced protein supplement, Muscle Milk may be the better option.

Goal-specific Considerations (weight Loss, Muscle Gain, Etc.)

If you’re struggling with alcoholism and looking to improve your physical health, it’s important to consider your fitness goals and how certain protein shakes can help. Here are some goal-specific considerations:

  • Weight loss: If you’re trying to lose weight, Fairlife may be a better option as it contains fewer calories and less sugar than Muscle Milk. However, both shakes should be consumed in moderation as they do contain calories.
  • Muscle gain: For those looking to build muscle, either shake can provide the necessary protein intake. However, Fairlife may be slightly better with higher protein content per serving.
  • Fitness performance: Both shakes can provide sustained energy for workouts due to their carbohydrate content, but Muscle Milk includes essential amino acids that aid in muscle recovery.
  • Bone density: The DDYNAMO trial suggests that higher dairy protein intake can improve bone mineral density during weight loss. Both shakes contain calcium and vitamin D which aid in bone health.
  • Insulin sensitivity: Drinking too much Muscle Milk has been associated with insulin resistance, making it less suitable for those with insulin sensitivity issues. Fairlife does not have this issue.

Remember to consult a healthcare professional before incorporating any new supplements into your diet.

Dietary Restrictions

For those with dietary restrictions, choosing between Muscle Milk and Fairlife may depend on the specific needs of their diet. For example, if lactose intolerance is an issue, Fairlife’s lactose-free options such as their Core Power shakes or filtered milk products may be a better choice.

Additionally, those who follow gluten-free diets can find solace knowing that Fairlife has been certified gluten-free by the Gluten Intolerance Group. On the other hand, for individuals looking to avoid artificial ingredients in their supplements or drinks, Muscle Milk may not be the best option due to its potential inclusion of these additives.

Taste Preferences

When it comes to choosing between Muscle Milk and Fairlife, taste preferences play a crucial role. Both products come in various flavors, and most of them have similar artificial sweeteners.

However, if you are looking for a protein shake without added sugars or artificial sweeteners, Fairlife might be the better option for you.

On the other hand, if you want a sweeter taste with more calories and sugar content than Fairlife’s shakes offer, then Muscle Milk might be your preferred choice.

Budget Constraints

For those on a tight budget, the cost of protein drinks like Muscle Milk and Fairlife can be a concern. It’s important to consider the price per serving when comparing these options.

For example, although Fairlife may be more expensive than regular milk, it might still be a more affordable choice than Muscle Milk due to its higher protein content and longer shelf life.

In school lunch programs where milk is regulated by nutritional standards, choosing between regular milk and ultra-filtered options like Fairlife can also have financial considerations.

While ultra-filtered milk may provide additional benefits such as lactose-free and gluten-free options, it could come at a higher cost compared to traditional dairy products that meet regulations.


In conclusion, when it comes to deciding between Muscle Milk and Fairlife, there are many factors to consider. Both beverages offer unique benefits and drawbacks that may appeal differently to individuals based on their goals, dietary restrictions, taste preferences, and budget constraints.

While Fairlife provides more protein per serving with less sugar than regular milk, its Core Power variant contains more calories and carbohydrates than Muscle Milk.

On the other hand, Muscle Milk offers a well-balanced nutritional option with essential amino acids for muscle growth and recovery but may contain artificial ingredients with higher calorie and sugar content than Fairlife.